Blair is caught off guard when she experiences her first crush on a boy.
- Ramon Reed as Owen Blatt
- Kaylin Hayman as Blair Bennett
- JC Currais as The Gator
- Suzi Barrett as Rachel Bennett
- Tobie Windham as Byron Blatt
- Orestes Arcuni as Loco Pollo Larry
- Isaiah Morgan as Milo
- Bryce Brown as G Shark Singer #1
- Lisa Pan as G Shark Singer #2
- Giovanna Bush as G Shark Singer #3
- The title is a reference to the 1999 horror film The Blair Witch Project.
- The vote winners are Baby Pig and Hammy Hogwarts, Loco Pollo Larry, and Flapjacks.
- Blair's middle name is Myrtle. This might be a reference to the character of the same name from the 2002 Disney movie, Lilo & Stitch.
- This is the second time DJ Lela B has a speaking role.